Yet again someone has an issue with public reporting

133
Rant - Yet again someone has an issue with public reporting

Doesn't this make you feel all warm and fuzzy about surfing:
------
As a HMB surfer it is nice to see your reports but may I kindly request
that you refrain from informing the cyberworld of some of the lesser known
spots in town.
-----

Dude, Its the internet.

Its a public beach, its empty, and I did not mention the spot where I was.

This has been done over and to death, Personally I would like to see 2-3 surfers at these spots when I paddle out for safety and someone to talk to in the line up.

These beach breaks are more advanced spots and will never be full of kooks (they can't make the paddle out just like OB, they take care of themselves), just because someone posts a morning video of a surf report from a lesser know spot doesn't mean the whole internet is going to come. Stokereport and Twitter are pretty tight communities that most of the internet doesn't pay attention to. It would be different if It was posted to say surfline.

Its a report, things change, information gets shared, deal with it. I post with my real name and real photo as I don't think hiding information behind a name like dudester is conductive to the community. I know most of the regular posters here on SR and I have met them in real life and they are good people and fun to surf with so why be so Anal Retentive about having someone know the conditions of the 4 miles of beach break we call Half Moon Bay?

This has been done to death here.
http://stokereport.com/rant/why-i-wont-be-posting-any-more-public-report...

What are you afraid of? that 4 or more people will make the trip from SF to surf one of our fabulous beach breaks in HMB?

Personally I would like to see a few people out at some of the tougher beach breaks in the morning, half the time I dawn patrol the jetty I do it solo, I surf the other beach breaks solo 80% of the time, the 20% being when I bring a friend with me.

I report so others can enjoy the waves and share the stoke. Its Half Moon Bay, they are public town and state beaches, they are not secret, they are not sacred, they are not crowded.

The thought that a simple fuzzy video on the internet showing this would change that fact is silly. Most people in SF think the world ends at Devils slide, I know this because I bug a lot of them to come surf with me and they don't because it is too far. Sharing that there is a another spot in Half Moon Bay beyond Mavericks or The Jetty can take the pressure off some of them and allow more waves for all.

Half Moon Bay is over 4 Miles long, there is plenty of beach break for all.

0
cryptomail (not verified)
2 years ago

Private email is private.

Zurffy
2 years ago

I understand the idea of wanting to keep a spot off the cyber radar but you're right: It'd be nice to hype a few other spots around to spread people out a little. And unless there's a hidden pipeline in HMB I don't think another long beachbreak will make any difference to the crowd down there.

His comment was pretty mellow...

I'm surprised how nice people are on this site. Totally different then vibes in the water. We are actually a nice group in real life.

deciblast
2 years ago

Keep what you're doing Luke. Hopefully I'll see you out there soon :)

lkilpatrick
2 years ago

I just get annoyed when someone signs up for this site specifically to bug me about reporting to the community that I am happy to be a part of.

I couldn't get out this morning, but I hope someone didn't let those nice waves go to waste. If someone went out and had a good time based on a report I gave then I would feel very good about it, that is the point.

tehdely
2 years ago

That person generated a lot of text.

Kooktastic
2 years ago

I didn't realize that the old-timers were sophisticated enough to use the Interwebs!

Imagining one can stop/control the flow of information around the Internet is like Florida thinking it can build a few levees to stay nice and dry when the Greenland glaciers melt. It's just not gonna happen. The world is always in a state of change. One can accept it and adapt to it or fight it and complain about life not being like the good ole days.

King of Kooks
2 years ago

The King agrees with the grouches that sometimes less is more when it comes to reporting. It is possible serve both the stoke needs and the privacy needs of the community at the same time.

Rev.MCC
2 years ago

wait there are secret spots in HMB?

dudester
2 years ago

I'm the grouch. I sent a PRIVATE email to Luke asking him to politely refrain from videoing some of the lesser known spots. I don’t have an issue with public reporting. It is helpful when I am deciding whether or not to leave work early to get a surf or whether I should be grumpy all day because I missed out on an epic session.

Yes, he didn’t name a spot but he did show all relevant land marks which is the same IMHO. It's a free country, you can do whatever you want but isn’t it sufficient to say that there is swell in the water, winds are offshore and the ocean is smooth in HMB and include a video of the waves without the landmarks so we can see if it is actually working or not?

lkilpatrick
2 years ago

Do you think if someone knew all of the landmarks that they wouldn't know about the spot already?

It was empty, no one was there and there was plenty of waves for lots of people. I doubt 1 person even went out. I personally wouldn't mind a few others surfing that spot, there is tons of waves but remote enough that having someone else in the water would be a good idea.

If you see the landmarks then you know the area well enough to know the spot, therefore secrecy of it is pointless.

If you know a spot well enough to know the landmarks, wouldn't you want to know if it was working?

H20MansLibrary
2 years ago

guys, you're hitting the coke vs. pepsi, israeli vs. palestinian, pro-choice vs. anti-abortion point here...i.e. no end in sight...

lkilpatrick
2 years ago

Your right H20, Dudester, welcome to Stokereport. No hard feelings. Maybe I overreacted a bit, I just get tired of all the protectionism of breaks that really don't need it, your email wasn't the first one I have seen, but I got annoyed with the appearance that you signed up to stokereport just to email me to stop reporting.

If you see me in the line up say hi, hope to see you at the riptide some wet wednesday night.

madpie
2 years ago

I just think it's funny to suppose that anybody would have watched that video of totally blah surf breaking on a weekday morning and gone "oh man, I just gotta call in sick, get in the car, and drive for half an hour to track down that spot with the head high closeouts."

I mean really. Does anybody think the waves in that video are particularly sexy? Or any different than the several miles of totally unsurfed ocean that any one of us could encounter at Sharp Park whenever we want?

That HMB beach is not empty because it's an obscure secret. It's empty because it's a remote, ho-hum beachbreak surrounded by miles of other remote, ho-hum beachbreaks.

surfergrrrl
2 years ago

What's wrong with hiding behind a name like, say, "surfergrrrl"?!
:-)

sticker
2 years ago

+1 @madpie. Was thinking the same thing. :)

tcannon
2 years ago

That video made me happy that I slept in. Your secret is safe with me!

Login or register to post comments